
The unique challenges of offshore drilling, unable to be overcome by traditional drilling approaches, have forced the industry to aggressively pursue alternative methods to ‘pump and dump’ top hole drilling. After nearly a decade of significant expenditure in the areas of research and development of dual gradient drilling technology, the offshore drilling community has seen fruition in the form of AGR Subsea’s Riserless Mud Recovery (RMR) system.
AGR Subsea first introduced its patented RMR system (also known as riserless dual gradient drilling) to the industry three years ago and it has since penetrated the offshore drilling landscape, helping to relieve the growing challenges presented by offshore drilling.
The fundamental challenges of offshore drilling are commonly augmented by distinct geology unique to particular regions. Seabed geology that possesses shallow geohazards introduces conditions such as soft soils, swelling clay, shallow gas and water flows, and even mud volcanoes, making it increasingly difficult to drill in those specific areas and increasing the likelihood of damaging wells by soil movement.
The traditional top hole approaches involve either drilling with full mud circulation to the surface through a riser or utilizing the ‘pump and dump’ methodology, which simply spills the mud and cuttings onto the seabed. Drilling top holes using riser is considered very risky in relation to shallow gas and is banned in many places such as the Norwegian continental shelf. The most prevalent top hole drilling problem associated with the use of these approaches is the dispelling of mud and cuttings, which has obvious environmental implications. Heightened focus on the discharge to the marine environment has propelled the adoption of RMR technology, as authorities have begun to place restrictions on the amount of discharge emitted to sea.
RMR differs from traditional drilling approaches in that instead of a riser pipe through the water column to extend the annulus around the drill pipe to the surface, the return flow is intercepted at the seabed and pumped to the surface as if the drilling had been moved to seabed level.
What attracts drilling prospects to the new technology is the ability to more closely mirror natural pressure conditions found in the borehole as it is steadily extended to full depth. A suction module is mounted at the top of the well and a nearby subsea pump sends mud and cuttings back to the surface drilling rig via an eight-inch hose, which enables the use of heavy mud compositions to overcome soft soil conditions.
The engineered fluid system relies upon a combination of specialized drilling fluids incompatible with the sea environment or too expensive to discharge to the seafloor. By applying greater overbalance than the mud in the hole at the time would impart via a mechanical means as opposed to mud weight hydrostatic alone, the riserless approach offers the potential to re-circulate the mud and ultimately extend the capacity for handling mud with high gravities. With the RMR system, it is now possible to handle mud with a specific gravity of up to 1.5 rather than the 1.1 limitation associated with a riser approach.
The special RMR system originated when AGR was exploring new methodology for moving drill cuttings at seabed level as an alternative to ‘pump and dump’ top hole drilling. After AGR installed their first subsea mud pump in 1997, they developed a patented cuttings transport system (CTS), which went into commercial use in 1998. The RMR technology evolved from this original cuttings system after seven years of development work.
The Caspian Sea was the first regional candidate RMR technology exerted its influence upon as the area is well known for its shallow geohazards, which require the special technology to overcome the condition difficulties. The world’s first commercial application of riserless drilling technology occurred there on the Azeri Field for BP in 2003. Since that time, a total of 15 wells have been successfully completed on the field using the RMR technology.
The RMR system has proven to offer a host of economic and environmental benefits. By enabling use of engineered fluid systems to displace the common ‘pump and dump’ mechanism, the system eliminates casing strings, improves wellbore stability and significantly reduces discharge to sea. In turn, RMR drastically improves drilling efficiency and offers considerable savings. The benefits have been hailed as substantial as a result of considerable savings in mud costs and logistics support costs to transport large fluid volumes to the rig site.
Over the course of the past three years, RMR has significantly penetrated the offshore drilling landscape and established itself as a viable and preferred alternative to traditional drilling approaches. RMR technology has emerged in the industry at an opportune time and promises to be a significant step in the evolution of deep-water drilling technology. Advancements that were once deemed impossible are now becoming tangible in light of the new technology.
RMR Track Record
AGR’s Riserless Mud Recovery system has been successfully applied to a number of shallow water riserless drilling applications during the last three years. Its first commercial application debuted on the Azeri Field in the Caspian Sea where a total of 15 wells have been successfully completed using RMR technology.
Three additional wells have been drilled on the deep-water Guneshli Field and one well on Shah Deniz for BP in the Caspian Sea. A North Sea field trial, funded by Demo 2000, Hydro, Statoil and AGR, was carried out in 2004 to qualify the RMR technology for the North Sea/NCS environment in water depths up to 1500 feet. The system has also been recently applied on one well for Total UK with another well planned for this autumn.
RMR was also selected for two exploration wells completed this summer in Shtokman in the Barents (Hydro/Gazprom) and in Sakhalin (BP) in order to meet discharge-to-environment requirements. AGR was also recently awarded a contract with Shell for 12 wells on the Western Australia Drilling Project, with operations expected to begin in November 2006.
Currently, a RMR joint industry project, labeled the Demo 2000 RMR Deepwater JIP, is in the organizational phase to field trial an updated look at the technology. Current participants of the JIP are Demo 2000, BP, Shell and AGR Subsea with field trials scheduled for the post hurricane season 2007 in the Gulf of Mexico.
Participants in the field trial will be devoted to developing and proving the technology as being a user-friendly, safe and cost-effective alternative to the conventional practice of riserless pumping and dumping up to 5000-foot water depths. Future field trials aim to prove the technical and commercial merits of riserless top hole drilling projects and will seek to continue development of its deep-water capability.
The merit of riserless mud recovery
Besides the fact that riserless drilling is an extremely efficient mechanism when making the top hole amid complex seabed conditions, the technology also possesses the capability to extend beyond the initial phase of exploration drilling.
The system allows the operator to collect used drilling fluid and cuttings from the seabed and pump back to the rig, which means that the goal of zero discharge can be attained during this stage in the drilling process. Before the drilling fluid is reused, the cuttings are then separated out on the rig. This is a significant advancement in the process since this drilling waste along with the drilling fluid was typically dumped onto the seabed.
The option to reuse drilling fluid is closely tied to the higher success rate for top hole drilling since operators can use drilling fluid of higher quality and such recycling offers both economic and environmental benefits. It also translates to a reduction in the amount of casing needed to stabilize the borehole, and the fluid provides effective pressure control to keep the oil or gas in place in the reservoir.
While RMR technology has been used exclusively during top hole drilling operations, results from the Caspian Sea operations reveal that this same technology may be successfully applied to deeper parts of the borehole. As long as an operator can maintain the pressure balance using heavier drilling fluids with the correct viscosity, many short lengths of casing may be replaced by a few long ones. This concept however requires the use of a pump to achieve effective pressure control. The end benefit to utilizing this process is reduced drilling time – possibly by as much as several weeks – which ultimately will cut down the expensive rig time.
AGR developers of the RMR system foresee a future where the entire drilling process may be accomplished without the use of risers, a venture feasible in theory. In such an instance, the need for expensive steel could be eliminated altogether, removing the enormous costs associated with placing several kilometer of steel pipe under the seabed. This development could result in astronomical savings per well across the industry.